November 16, 2024

Donald Trump’s tenure as President of the United States sparked widespread debate on many fronts, including U.S. foreign policy towards Africa. His infamous characterization of African nations as “shithole countries” was condemned worldwide. Beyond the offensive language, though, it raises the question: was Trump fundamentally wrong about the challenges facing the continent? Africa, with its 54 diverse nations, grapples with numerous issues, including governance, social services, and economic development. Acknowledging these problems is crucial for driving meaningful change.

Facing Africa’s Challenges

Africa’s struggles with infrastructure, education, and governance are well-documented. Many countries on the continent still contend with inadequate public services, high poverty rates, and limited access to essential utilities like water and electricity. Concededly, not all African nations face these challenges equally, but a substantial number are in the throes of significant development hurdles.

Confronting these issues head-on rather than shying away from them is integral to progress. Dismissing or ignoring the continent’s problems would hinder efforts to improve living standards and create opportunities for African people. Instead, recognizing and addressing these hurdles could inspire internal reforms and partnerships that prioritize Africa’s needs over external influences.

“America First” and Its Implications

Trump’s “America First” policy put American interests squarely at the forefront of his administration’s actions, often at the expense of traditional multilateral engagement. While this approach has its critics, it is hardly unique. Historically, all U.S. presidents have ultimately prioritized their nation’s agenda, even those who have publicly professed a commitment to Africa.

Aid and foreign military bases in Africa have often been tools of furthering U.S. geopolitical interests rather than purely altruistic endeavors. This underscores the stark reality that African countries must assert their interests instead of relying on foreign aid and intervention, which have not always advanced the continent’s welfare.

Beyond Dependency on Aid

A potential positive aspect of Trump’s disengagement from international aid is the opportunity it presents for African nations to reevaluate their economic strategies. Reducing dependency on foreign aid could serve as a catalyst for African countries to strengthen intra-continental trade and development. Currently, intra-African trade stands at a mere 13%, showcasing a significant untapped potential for economic collaboration within the continent.

The storyline of Africa’s abundant natural resources often highlights the export of raw materials, which are processed and sold at higher values by other nations. Africa stands to gain considerably from retaining and processing its resources locally, thus adding value and generating economic growth within the continent. This transformation could redefine Africa’s position in the global market, encouraging foreign direct investment in sectors that align with Africa’s long-term goals.

Mali’s Example: A Case for Self-Reliance

Mali presents a compelling case for self-reliance and reform. The country recently took significant steps to clear its debts with international financial institutions like the IMF and the World Bank, focusing on policies that encourage domestic processing of raw materials. Although Mali’s political landscape is troubled, its economic strategies inspire a broader African movement toward financial independence and self-determination.

By rejecting IMF and World Bank loans, Mali challenges the conventional notion of development assistance, which often comes with strings attached. The debate around aid and economic assistance, as highlighted in books like “Confessions of an Economic Hitman,” suggests that international financial aid has sometimes served more to exploit Africa’s resources than to aid genuine economic development.

The Path Forward for African Leadership

African leaders must engage in deep reflection to forge a path that is independent of external controls. Aligning themselves with the agendas of Western powers has not always brought about favorable outcomes for African citizens. Instead, prioritizing regional integration, strengthening governance, and investing in local capacities are crucial steps toward a sustainable future.

As Trump’s “America First” policy inadvertently signals the end of an era of dependence on foreign aid, African leaders have a unique opportunity to redefine the continent’s approach to development. This transition away from handouts towards mutual cooperation within Africa is not merely a necessity but a strategic advantage. Solutions to Africa’s challenges are most effective when they originate from within and cater to the specific needs and contexts of its diverse cultures and economies.

Case Study: East Africa in the Context of U.S.-Africa Relations Under Trump

The East African region presents a dynamic interplay of geopolitical interests and socio-economic challenges. A closer look at countries like Uganda and Kenya reveals how their relationships with the U.S. have been influenced by both internal policies and international stances, particularly under leaders like Donald Trump, who prioritize national interests over global ideological conformity.

Uganda: Navigating International Backlash

Uganda recently faced significant international backlash, including funding cuts and removal from the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) benefits, due to its stance on LGBTQ+ issues. The country’s hardline policies in this area contrasted with the prevailing international advocacy for LGBTQ+ rights, leading to strained relations with the U.S. and other Western nations.

A Potential Re-engagement with the U.S.:

– Alignment on National Interests: With Trump potentially in office, Uganda might find an administration more focused on mutual national interests rather than ideological conformity. Trump has openly criticized what he considers overreach by multilateral institutions and international norms that do not align with domestic priorities. This could open a window for Uganda to engage based on economic and security interests rather than social policy changes.

– Focus on Stability and Security: Uganda plays a crucial role in regional stability, especially in conflict-affected areas such as South Sudan and Somalia. This strategic importance could serve as a basis for re-engaging with the U.S., emphasizing joint security objectives over contentious social issues.

– Economic Opportunities: While Uganda needs to navigate the repercussions of its policies, the potential shift in U.S. focus away from ideological to more pragmatic engagements could allow for renewed economic cooperation, focusing on areas like trade and investment without the conditionalities tied to social policy reform.

Kenya: Balancing Act with the West

Kenya has historically maintained a close relationship with the U.S., underscored by shared security interests and economic ties. Recent interactions, such as President Ruto’s visit to the Oval Office and CIA engagements, highlight Kenya’s strategic importance. However, under a Trump administration, this relationship might face new dynamics.

Potential Shifts with Trump:

– Reduced Influence of Multilateral Organizations: President Ruto’s inclination towards IMF policies could face challenges under Trump’s skepticism of multilateral financial institutions. A shift in U.S. policy might lead to reduced reliance on financial assistance channeled through these organizations, urging Kenya to seek alternative economic strategies and domestic financial reforms.

– Re-evaluation of Bilateral Ties: The personal rapport seen between President Ruto and President Biden might not seamlessly translate into the same under Trump. The U.S.-Kenya relationship could move towards more transactional dealings, focusing on specific mutual benefits in trade and security.

– Encouragement of Self-reliance and Innovation: With potentially reduced financial aid, Kenya might accelerate efforts towards self-reliance, encouraging more innovation in sectors like technology and entrepreneurship. This shift may foster greater resilience and adaptability within Kenya’s economy, pushing for reforms that align more closely with local needs and priorities.

Strategic Implications for East Africa

For the East Africa region comprised of 8 countries (Kenya, Uganda, Tanzania, Burundi, Rwanda, Democratic Republic of Congo, South Sudan and Somalia), the return of Trump could signify a shift towards engagements that leverage regional strengths and focus on pragmatic collaboration. Both nations might have to recalibrate their foreign policies to prioritize regional partnerships and internal development to hedge against volatile international alliances.

The East Africa Community (EAC) must strengthen regional integration which will provide a buffer against unreliable foreign aid, promoting economic growth from within the continent. Collaborative projects in infrastructure and trade could enhance economic resilience. All EAC nations can benefit from investing in local industries and human capital. By reducing dependency on foreign aid, they could foster environments conducive to sustainable economic growth and innovation. Finally, security collaborations remain a pillar of U.S.-East Africa relations. By positioning the bloc as indispensable partner in the fight against terrorism and regional conflicts, the regional bloc could leverage their strategic roles to maintain strong ties with the U.S.

Conclusion

The legacy of Trump’s presidency in Africa may very well lie in its challenge to the status quo. While his rhetoric and policies often clashed with global expectations, they underscore the urgent need for Africa to chart its destiny independently. African unity, economic integration, and self-reliance could set a foundation for a future where Africa truly thrives, not just as a recipient of aid, but as a formidable global player in its own right.

Get your FREE guide on how to build a successful business in East Africa.

Enter your details below and we'll send over your free guide right away to the email address you provide.

You have Successfully Subscribed!